## Summary
This PR fixes an issue where the backup folder was being created
unnecessarily when users navigated to the General tab in PowerToys
Settings, even when no actual backup had been triggered.
## Problem
When opening PowerToys Settings and navigating to the General tab, the
backup directory (default: `~/Documents/PowerToys/Backup`) was
automatically created, even though no backup operation had been
performed. This caused confusion for users setting up PowerToys on new
devices, as they would always need to manually clean up the unwanted
default folder when configuring a custom backup path.
## Root Cause
The issue occurred because:
1. Loading the General tab triggers `RefreshBackupRestoreStatus()`
2. This calls `DryRunBackup()` to check backup status
3. `DryRunBackup()` executes `BackupSettingsInternal()` with
`dryRun=true`
4. However, the directory creation logic (`TryCreateDirectory`) was
running regardless of the dry run flag
## Solution
The fix ensures that directory creation only happens during actual
backup operations:
**Primary Change**: Wrapped backup directory creation in a dry run
check:
```csharp
// Only create the backup directory if this is not a dry run
if (!dryRun)
{
var dirExists = TryCreateDirectory(settingsBackupAndRestoreDir);
if (!dirExists)
{
Logger.LogError($"Failed to create dir {settingsBackupAndRestoreDir}");
return (false, $"General_SettingsBackupAndRestore_BackupError", "Error", lastBackupExists, "\n" + settingsBackupAndRestoreDir);
}
}
```
**Consistency Change**: Also moved temporary directory creation inside
dry run checks to maintain consistent behavior throughout the backup
process.
## Impact
- ✅ **General tab loading**: No longer creates unwanted backup
directories
- ✅ **Actual backup functionality**: Remains completely unchanged
- ✅ **User experience**: Clean setup without unwanted default folders
- ✅ **No breaking changes**: All existing backup/restore features work
as before
## Testing
Created comprehensive tests to validate:
- Dry runs (General tab loading) don't create directories
- Actual backup operations create directories as expected
- No regression in existing backup/restore functionality
Fixes#38620.
> [!WARNING]
>
> <details>
> <summary>Firewall rules blocked me from connecting to one or more
addresses (expand for details)</summary>
>
> #### I tried to connect to the following addresses, but was blocked by
firewall rules:
>
> - `i1qvsblobprodcus353.vsblob.vsassets.io`
> - Triggering command: `dotnet build
src/settings-ui/Settings.UI.Library/Settings.UI.Library.csproj -c Debug
--nologo` (dns block)
>
> If you need me to access, download, or install something from one of
these locations, you can either:
>
> - Configure [Actions setup
steps](https://gh.io/copilot/actions-setup-steps) to set up my
environment, which run before the firewall is enabled
> - Add the appropriate URLs or hosts to the custom allowlist in this
repository's [Copilot coding agent
settings](https://github.com/microsoft/PowerToys/settings/copilot/coding_agent)
(admins only)
>
> </details>
<!-- START COPILOT CODING AGENT TIPS -->
---
✨ Let Copilot coding agent [set things up for
you](https://github.com/microsoft/PowerToys/issues/new?title=✨+Set+up+Copilot+instructions&body=Configure%20instructions%20for%20this%20repository%20as%20documented%20in%20%5BBest%20practices%20for%20Copilot%20coding%20agent%20in%20your%20repository%5D%28https://gh.io/copilot-coding-agent-tips%29%2E%0A%0A%3COnboard%20this%20repo%3E&assignees=copilot)
— coding agent works faster and does higher quality work when set up for
your repo.
---------
Co-authored-by: copilot-swe-agent[bot] <198982749+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: yeelam-gordon <73506701+yeelam-gordon@users.noreply.github.com>
* [Deps] Upgrade Framework Libraries to .NET 9 RC2
* [Common][Build] Update TFM to NET9
* [FileLocksmith][Build] Update TFM to NET9 in Publish Profile
* [PreviewPane][Build] Update TFM to NET9 in Publish Profile
* [PTRun][Build] Update TFM to NET9 in Publish Profile
* [Settings][Build] Update TFM to NET9 in Publish Profile
* [MouseWithoutBorders][Analyzers] Resolve WFO1000 by configuring Designer Serialization Visibility
* [Deps] Update Microsoft.CodeAnalysis.NetAnalyzers
* [Analyzers] Set CA1859,CA2263,CA2022 to be excluded from error
* [MouseWithoutBorders] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [ColorPicker] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [AdvancedPaste] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [TextExtractor] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [Hosts] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [MouseJump] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [PTRun] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [Wox] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [Peek] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [PowerAccent] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [Settings] Use System.Threading.Lock to lock instead of object instance
* [Deps] Update NOTICE.md
* [CI] Update .NET version step to target 9.0
* [Build] Attempt to add manual trigger for using Visual Studio Preview for building
* [Build] Fix variable typo
* [Build][Temporary] set to use preview builds
* [Build] Add missing parameters
* [Build][Temporary] directly hardcode preview image
* [Build][Temporary] Trying ImageOverride
* [Build] Revert hardcode and use ImageOverride
* [Build] Add env var for adding prerelease argument for vswhere
* [Build] Update VCToolsVersion script to use env var to optionally add prerelease version checking
* [Build] Remove unneeded parameter
* [Build] Re-add parameter in all the right places
* [CI][Build] Add NoWarn NU5104 when building with VS Preview
* [Deps] Update to stable .NET 9 packages
* [Deps] Update NOTICE.md
* Everything is WPF and WindowsForms now to fix .NET 9 dependency conflicts
* Ensure .NET 9 SDK for tests too
---------
Co-authored-by: Jaime Bernardo <jaime@janeasystems.com>
* Working UI update with just runProgram Path and isRunProgram
* First working, basic. no args or path, or setting change detections.
* Revert and fixed.
* Some clean up, working with config file monitor
* Args and Start-in should be working.
* File monitor, quotes, xaml screens one
* Fixed enable/disable toogle from XAML
* Code cleanup.
* Betting logging.
* Cleanup, start of RunProgramDescriptor and usage of run_non_elevated/run_elevated
* Code moved to KeyboardEventHandlers, but not enabled since it won't build as is, needs elevation.h. Other testing..
* Key chords working, pretty much
* Added gui for elevation level, need to refresh on change...
* f: include shellapi.h and reference wil in KBMEL
* run_elevated/run_non_elevated sorted out. Working!
* Removed lots of old temp code.
* Fix some speling errors.
* Cleanup before trying to add a UI for the chord
* Added "DifferentUser" option
* Closer on UI for chords.
* Better UI, lots working.
* Clean up
* Text for “Allow chords” – needs to look better…
* Bugs and clean-up
* Cleanup
* Refactor and clean up.
* More clean up
* Some localization.
* Don’t show “Allow chords“ to the “to” shortcut
* Maybe better foreground after opening new app
* Better chord matching.
* Runprogram fix for stealing existing shortcut.
* Better runProgram stuff
* Temp commit
* Working well
* Toast test
* More toast
* Added File and Folder picker UI
* Pre-check on run program file exists.
* Refactor to SetupRunProgramControls
* Open URI UI is going.
* Open URI working well
* Open URI stuff working well
* Allowed AppSpecific shortcut and fixed backup/restore shortcut dups
* Fixed settings screen
* Start of code to find by name...
* UI fixed
* Small fixes
* Some single edit code working.
* UI getting better.
* Fixes
* Fixed and merge from main
* UI updates
* UI updates.
* UI stuff
* Fixed crash from move ui item locations.
* Fixed crash from move ui item locations.
* Added delete confirm
* Basic sound working.
* Localized some stuff
* Added sounds
* Better experiance when shortcut is in use.
* UI tweaks
* Fixed KBM ui for unicode shortcut not having ","
* Some clean up
* Cleanup
* Cleanup
* Fixed applyXamlStyling
* Added back stuff lost in merge
* applyXamlStyling, again
* Fixed crash on change from non shortcut to shortcut
* Update src/modules/keyboardmanager/KeyboardManagerEngineTest/KeyboardManagerEngineTest.vcxproj
* Fixed some spelling type issues.
* ImplementationLibrary 231216
* Comment bump to see if the Microsoft.Windows.ImplementationLibrary version thing gets picked up
* Correct, Microsoft.Windows.ImplementationLibrary, finally?
* Fixed two test that failed because we now allow key-chords.
* Removed shortcut sounds.
* use original behavior when "allow chords" is off in shortcut window
* fix crash when editing a shortcut that has apps specified for it
* split KBM chords with comma on dashboard page
* Fix some spelling items.
* More "spelling"
* Fix XAML styling
* align TextBlock and ToggleSwitch
* fix cutoff issue at the top
* increase ComboBox width
* Added *Unsupported* for backwards compat on config of KBM
* fix spellcheck
* Fix crash on Remap key screen
* Fixed Remap Keys ComboBox width too short.
* Removed KBM Single Edit mode, fixed crash.
* Fix Xaml with xaml cops
* Fix crash on setting "target app" for some types of shortcuts.
* Space to toggle chord, combobox back
* fix spellcheck
* fix some code nits
* Code review updates.
* Add exclusions to the bug report tool
* Code review and kill CloseAndEndTask
* Fix alignment / 3 comboboxes per row
* Fix daily telemetry events to exclude start app and open URI
* Add chords and remove app start and open uri from config telemetry
* comma instead of plus in human readable shortcut telemetry data
* Code review, restore default-old state when new row added in KBM
* Code review, restore default-old state when new row added in KBM, part 2
* Still show target app on Settings
* Only allow enabling chords for origin shortcuts
---------
Co-authored-by: Andrey Nekrasov <yuyoyuppe@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Jaime Bernardo <jaime@janeasystems.com>
* Upgraded projects to target .NET 8
* Updated .NET runtime package targets to use latest .NET 8 build
* Updated PowerToys Interop to target .NET 8
* Switch to use ArgumentNullException.ThrowIfNull
* ArgumentNullException.ThrowIfNull for CropAndLockViewModel
* Switching to ObjectDisposedException.ThrowIf
* Upgrade System.ComponentModel.Composition to 8.0
* ArgumentNullException.ThrowIfNull in Helper
* Switch to StartsWith using StringComparison.Ordinal
* Disabled CA1859, CA1716, SYSLIB1096 analyzers
* Update RIDs to reflect breaking changes in .NET 8
* Updated Microsoft NuGet packages to RC1
* Updated Analyzer package to latest .NET 8 preview package
* CA1854: Use TryGetValue instead of ContainsKey
* [Build] Update TFM to .NET 8 for publish profiles
* [Analyzers] Remove CA1309, CA1860-CA1865, CA1869, CA2208 from warning.
* [Analyzers] Fix for C26495
* [Analyzers] Disable CS1615, CS9191
* [CI] Target .NET 8 in YAML
* [CI] Add .NET preview version flag temporarily.
* [FileLocksmith] Update TFM to .NET 8
* [CI] Switch to preview agent
* [CI] Update NOTICE.md
* [CI] Update Release to target .NET 8 and use Preview agent
* [Analyzers] Disable CA1854
* Fix typo
* Updated Microsoft.CodeAnalysis.NetAnalyzers to latest preview
Updated packages to rc2
* [Analyzers][CPP] Turn off warning for 5271
* [Analyzers][CPP] Turn off warning for 26493
* [KeyboardListener] Add mutex include to resolve error
* [PT Run][Folder] Use static SearchValues to resolve CA1870
* [PowerLauncher] Fix TryGetValue
* [MouseJumpSettings] Use ArgumentNullException.ThrowIfNull
* [Build] Disable parallel dotnet tool restore
* [Build] No cache of dotnet tool packages
* [Build] Temporarily move .NET 8 SDK task before XAML formatting
* [Build][Temp] Try using .NET 7 prior to XAML formatting and then switch to .NET 8 after
* [Build] Use .NET 6 for XAML Styler
* [CI] Updated NOTICE.md
* [FancyZones] Update TFM to .NET 8
* [EnvVar] Update TFM to .NET 8 and update RID
* [EnvVar] Use ArgumentNullException.ThrowIfNull
* [Dev] Updated packages to .NET 8 RTM version
* [Dev] Updated Microsoft.CodeAnalysis.NetAnalyzers to latest
* [CI] Updated NOTICE.md with latest package versions
* Fix new utility target fameworks and runtimeids
* Don't use preview images anymore
* [CI] Add script to update VCToolsVersion environment variable
* [CI] Add Step to Verify VCToolsVersion
* [CI] Use latest flag for vswhere to set proper VCToolsVersion
* Add VCToolsVersion checking to release.yml
* Remove net publishing from local/ PR CI builds
* Revert "Remove net publishing from local/ PR CI builds"
This reverts commit f469778996.
* Only publish necessary projects
* Add verbosity to release pipelines builds of PowerTOys
* Set VCToolsVersion for publish.cmd when called from installer
* [Installer] Moved project publish logic to MSBuild Task
* [CI] Revert using publish.cmd
* [CI] Set VCToolsVersion and unset ClearDevCommandPromptEnvVars property
* Installer publishes for x64 too
* Revert "Add verbosity to release pipelines builds of PowerTOys"
This reverts commit 654d4a7f78.
* [Dev] Update CodeAnalysis library to non-preview package
* Remove unneeded warning removal
* Fix Notice.md
* Rename VCToolsVersion file and task name
* Remove unneeded mutex header include
---------
Co-authored-by: Jaime Bernardo <jaime@janeasystems.com>
Fixes simple typo/grammar errors
It's easier to understand if it is spelled correctly. This is especially important for those for whom english may not be their first language.
Signed-off-by: brian teeman <brian@teeman.net>
